Menu of Mister Softee Santa Barbara in Santa Barbara, California, USA

Menu Overview

Mister Softee Santa Barbara, located at 935 State St, offers a nostalgic yet refreshing ice cream experience that captures the essence of classic soft serve with a modern twist. This charming ice cream shop, helmed by the welcoming owner Eden, provides not only quality but warmth in service that guests like James Magdalin and Michael Daoud rave about.

The menu highlights stand out distinctly—Oreo and Chocolate Ice Cream deliver rich, creamy textures, while the Hot Fudge topping elevates each bite with its deep, velvety sweetness. Their sundaes, featuring flavors like Strawberry, Cherry, Butterscotch, and Pineapple, offer a delightful spectrum of options, each crafted with care. The shakes menu is equally impressive, boasting inventive choices like Mint Chip, Sea Salt & Caramel, and the classic Vanilla and Chocolate, ensuring variety without sacrificing quality.

One cannot overlook the specialty items such as the Brownie sundae paired with Rootbeer, priced at $9.75—a perfect indulgence that marries the dense, chocolatey brownie with a fizzy, nostalgic soda. The $8.75 Hot Fudge sundae captures simplicity done right, grounded in rich flavors that comfort and delight.

What sets Mister Softee apart is its authentic New York City vibe at an accessible price. Christopher Archer’s observation about the “NYC ice cream taste” rings true here; the soft serve is smooth and flavorful, served in generous portions that satisfy both the palate and the wallet. The option to have both vanilla and chocolate soft serve—dipped or plain—is a rarity and contributes to the distinct character of Mister Softee’s offerings.

The atmosphere adds to the experience. Tom Piszczek highlights the friendly staff and clean, inviting space, making it a place not just to grab a quick snack, but to linger and enjoy. Customer Michael Merenda’s reflective nostalgia echoes the emotional connection many have with Mister Softee—a brand that rekindles childhood memories while inviting new ones to be made.

In summary, Mister Softee Santa Barbara excels through its carefully curated menu, balancing classic favorites like Oreo and Hot Fudge with inventive combinations. The warm, welcoming service and authentic New York spirit make it a must-visit destination for anyone craving soft serve ice cream with soul. Whether you’re in the mood for a robust shake or a classic sundae, this spot feels like home, one sweet scoop at a time.